What’s cryptocurrency worth when two parties cannot agree on who owns it or how to split ownership?
It may seem easy to check the current price of your crypto holdings online, but a legal dispute makes it much more complicated. When cryptocurrency disputes become part of a divorce, a business buyout, or a restructuring, the cryptocurrency’s valuation can depend on many factors.
Why crypto is uniquely hard to value in a dispute
Although there is some correlation, cryptocurrency behaves differently from the stock market, and one major difference is that it has no set market hours. It trades around the clock, so prices can move day and night. Prices can change significantly within a single day, and different exchanges may report slightly different values for the same asset.
With smaller tokens, this can be even trickier because low demand often makes the actual market value unclear. While blue-chip tokens such as BTC or ETH generally have some market liquidity, this isn’t necessarily the case for some niche tokens, or even exotic blockchain products like NFTs. These assets may have real value, but their prices are far more volatile, and selling them can be very difficult.
For example, someone might hold cryptocurrency with a quoted market value of $500,000. But when they decide to sell the entire position, insufficient demand could lower the price. Furthermore, questions about liquidity in the markets where this cryptocurrency trades, the asset’s trading volume, and unreliable exchange reporting (such as wash trading) can raise questions about the true value of the quoted prices.
What do valuation experts do when cryptocurrency is part of a legal dispute?
In legal disputes, clients and their attorney often work with a valuation professional experienced in analyzing digital assets, such as a business valuation specialist; alternatively, they may work with a forensic accountant with relevant valuation expertise.
This professional evaluates the holdings and supporting financial data to develop a defensible valuation under the legal standard that applies to the dispute.
Fair value vs. fair market value: which standard applies?
One of the first questions in a cryptocurrency valuation dispute is which standard, fair value or fair market value, should apply.
Generally, fair market value is the price at which a willing buyer and seller exchange property without either party feeling forced into the transaction, assuming each party is well informed. For federal tax purposes, the IRS treats cryptocurrency as property under Notice 2014-21, making fair market value relevant when determining taxable amounts.
In contrast, while several definitions exist for statutory fair value, each depends on the jurisdictional rules governing the situation. For example, during statutory buyouts of shareholders, statutory fair value reflects an owner’s percentage ownership interest in a business entity but often excludes discounts that may apply in ordinary transactions between parties. New Jersey courts, for example, generally do not apply marketability discounts in oppressed-shareholder buyouts absent extraordinary circumstances.
It should also be noted that accounting fair value under FASB ASC 820 has its own separate set of guidelines regarding orderly transactions between “market participants.”
Therefore, it is important to identify the proper definition of fair value to determine how much an asset or ownership interest is worth in any type of litigation. Below is a visual breakdown:
| Fair market value | Statutory fair value |
|---|---|
| Based on a hypothetical willing-buyer and willing-seller transaction | Determined under applicable statutory or judicial rules |
| Commonly relevant to tax matters and business transactions | Commonly relevant to shareholder buyouts and appraisal proceedings |
| May account for ownership and liquidity discounts | May exclude certain discounts, depending on state law |
Why the valuation date can change everything
Traditional business valuations may reflect gradual changes in financial performance over several months, whereas cryptocurrency prices can swing rapidly during a pending lawsuit.
Depending on the timing, a holding worth $600,000 when a complaint is filed could be worth more or less when the parties agree to settle. Which date controls therefore often becomes a primary point of contention.
The following example shows how using two different dates for the same amount of BTC can produce vastly different valuations, with no change to the number of coins or the type of coin.
| Valuation date | Price per BTC | Total value |
|---|---|---|
| Date A | $60,000 | $600,000 |
| Date B | $75,000 | $750,000 |
| Date C | $45,000 | $450,000 |
In the example above, the difference between the highest and lowest valuations is $300,000. Statutes, contracts, or the courts can determine the controlling date depending on the circumstances. In a New Jersey divorce, for example, assets are generally valued as of the filing of the complaint, while in a New Jersey oppressed-shareholder buyout the statute generally looks to the date the action was filed, subject to the court’s discretion.
Valuing the tokens themselves
Once the valuation standard and date are established, the valuation professional examines the market evidence supporting the tokens’ value. For actively traded assets such as BTC or ETH, that means reviewing exchange prices and trading activity to identify a supportable price, not simply accepting a quote from a single platform.
When trading is limited, the analysis becomes less straightforward. The professional examines whether recent transactions provide reliable pricing evidence, whether enough buyers exist to support the quoted price, and whether restrictions affect the holder’s ability to sell.
The central question is whether the available evidence supports the reported value of the holdings, rather than just a published price for an individual token.
Valuing the crypto business behind the tokens
Valuing a cryptocurrency business involves much more than valuing the cryptocurrencies it owns. Businesses such as mining operations and exchanges can own assets like equipment, incur ongoing expenses, enter into contractual agreements, and generate income through various means.
In these cases, valuation professionals generally use traditional methods, adjusted to account for the unique risks of investing in the cryptocurrency market.
Market and cost approaches, including mining rigs and mined inventory
The market approach estimates a company’s value using comparable businesses or transactions. An asset-based approach estimates value as assets minus liabilities.
For a cryptocurrency mining business, an asset-based analysis could include the current value of mining equipment, accounting for its condition and technological obsolescence, as well as the value of mined cryptocurrency the business holds.
An asset-based valuation may not fully capture the value of the business’s ongoing operations and earning potential.
Discounted cash flow for cash-flowing operations
A discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis can be useful when a business’s future cash flows can be reasonably estimated. It converts those projected cash flows into a present value, accounting for the time value of money and the risks associated with the projections.
For a cryptocurrency mining business, the cash-flow forecast would account for expected mining revenue, electricity and other operating costs, and equipment replacement needs. Assumptions about token prices and mining difficulty would affect those projections.
DCF is therefore generally more applicable to an operating business with forecastable cash flows than to a token that generates no underlying cash flows.
| Valuation approach | Typical application |
|---|---|
| Market approach | Actively traded tokens and comparable business transactions |
| Income approach | Staking rewards and businesses generating cash flows |
| Cost or asset-based approach | Mining equipment, token inventories, and underlying net assets |
How minority and marketability discounts affect the number
Valuation discounts can impact the ownership value of a cryptocurrency business. The minority discount reflects the lack of control that comes with a non-controlling ownership interest. The marketability discount accounts for the lack of an existing or established market to sell an ownership interest.
For example, if you apply a hypothetical 20% marketability discount to an ownership interest worth $1 million, the discounted value would be $800,000. But courts will not always allow such discounts in all legal proceedings. As discussed above, statutory fair-value standards can limit the adjustments that can be made when determining fair value.
In general, whether a discount applies depends on the applicable laws and the specific circumstances of the ownership interest.
Where crypto valuation disputes arise
Several forms of litigation involve cryptocurrency valuation, including shareholder buyouts or partnership disputes, divorces, damages actions against businesses, estate disputes, and bankruptcies.
Investment funds and their investors can also dispute the net asset value of a portfolio that includes restricted or thinly traded digital currencies. While the same digital currency could be involved in all of these forms of litigation, the law applicable to each form of litigation, and thus the legal criteria for the valuation of that cryptocurrency, will likely vary significantly.
Why getting the valuation right matters
When substantial cryptocurrency holdings are involved, a disagreement over the valuation standard, date, or applicable discounts can change a case’s outcome by hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars.
Attorneys may consult forensic accountants, valuation specialists, and/or expert witnesses to analyze financial data and determine a reasonable, defensible value. Preserving historical wallet activity, exchange statement history, transactional history, and other relevant business documents early in a dispute will likely help this process significantly.
Get legal guidance for a cryptocurrency valuation dispute
When cryptocurrency is part of a legal dispute, disagreements over the valuation date, pricing evidence, or applicable discounts can have significant financial consequences. Resolving those questions requires understanding both the assets involved and the legal rules governing the dispute.
At the Law Offices of Andrew Dressel LLC, we help clients navigate cryptocurrency litigation and business disputes. Andrew Dressel has represented partners in disputes involving a cryptocurrency investment company and a bitcoin mining company.
Contact our team to discuss the valuation issues in your case and how we can help you address them.
The content in this article is for general informational purposes only. It should not be construed as legal advice or a substitute for legal advice. The information above does not create an attorney-client relationship, nor do prior results guarantee future outcomes. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.