In a crypto company, a disagreement over strategic direction can quickly turn into a battle for control.
In many crypto companies, ownership on paper and control of the company’s digital assets sit with different people. When a disagreement starts, that split determines who can act.
Where crypto ownership disputes start and why
In some cases, a founder controls all of the company’s private keys, which allow them to transfer money out of the company. In other cases, an operations manager runs the company’s day-to-day activities but doesn’t have access to the company treasury.
Combine that with fluctuating crypto-related assets, members of the founding team working remotely, and sometimes even relying on pseudonyms in communications, and it can take little time for a disagreement over strategic direction to turn into a battle for control of the company.
Beyond disagreements over management and ownership, cryptocurrency companies operate in an industry where control over digital assets carries significant financial consequences.
The most common partner and shareholder disputes in crypto
Freeze-outs and loss of access
A freeze-out occurs when those who control a company exclude another owner from participating in the business or receiving information.
For example, if you are a member or shareholder of a crypto company, being removed from company dashboards or accounts or being unable to review important account-related activities could all be examples of freeze-outs. The question then becomes whether those actions violate the law, which depends on the individual’s rights as an owner and which laws apply to their situation.
Control of wallets, keys, and the treasury
Whoever controls a cryptocurrency wallet has de facto authority to transfer the assets in that wallet, even if other parties claim those assets.
While multisig wallets can reduce this risk by requiring multiple approved individuals to authorize a transfer, the same dispute risks still exist. For example, a dispute could allow one party to restrict another party’s ability to operate the business by using signature rights to block vendor payments or the movement of assets needed for continued operation.
When founders disagree, identifying who can approve transfers becomes especially important. Take a cryptocurrency company owned equally by two founders, with $2 million in its digital asset treasury. The company uses a wallet requiring two of three authorized signatures to move funds. If one founder controls two signing keys while the other controls only one, the first founder may be able to authorize transfers independently, even though both own 50% of the business.
| Metric | Founder A | Founder B |
| Company ownership | 50% | 50% |
| Authorized signing keys controlled | 2 of 3 | 1 of 3 |
| Share of signing keys | 66.7% | 33.3% |
| Can independently authorize a transfer? | Yes | No |
A co-owner may ask a court for a preliminary injunction restricting the use of company assets. But blockchain transactions can’t be reversed once made, and keys may be held by people outside the court’s reach, so speed matters.
Token and equity allocation fights
Disputes often arise from disagreements over how much equity founders were to receive. An individual may have believed they had a 30% ownership stake in the company for their early development efforts, but the cap table may show less. The number of shareholders and who holds which types of equity can also create confusion.
Resolving these disputes will involve reviewing all applicable documentation related to shareholder agreements, operating agreements, token allocations, and communications about those allocations. Holding a governance token generally isn’t the same as owning shares in a corporation or a membership interest in an LLC. However, an exception exists when the company’s governing documents tie membership to token holdings, as some DAO LLC structures allow.
Breach of fiduciary duty and self-dealing
A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when someone who owes legal duties to another person or entity violates those obligations. Business-related lawsuits involving fiduciary duties typically have two primary components:
- Duty of loyalty: covers conflicts of interest or inappropriate self-dealing
- Duty of care: addresses how certain business decisions were made
The specific duties owed depend on the entity type, the governing state’s law, and the company’s own agreements, which in some states can restrict or eliminate those duties. Some possible breaches of fiduciary duties are similar to those in non-crypto industries.
Examples include (but aren’t limited to):
- Diverting treasury funds into a personal digital wallet
- Entering into a transaction with the company for personal profit without disclosure or proper approval
- Taking a business opportunity that belonged to the company without first offering it to the company
Co-founder deadlock
When two co-founders have equal voting power, they cannot make major business decisions without each other’s consent. For example, they can disagree on how much money to raise for funding or whether to sell some of the company’s cryptocurrency assets. In many cases, this impasse prevents the business from moving forward.
This means that when the governing documents don’t include a dispute-resolution mechanism, the parties usually need to consider mediation or a buyout. That said, if the parties cannot resolve their disputes through these methods, they may need to seek relief from the court as a last resort. In New Jersey, for example, courts have statutory authority to grant relief to oppressed shareholders (N.J.S.A. 14A:12-7) and to dissolve an LLC that can no longer reasonably carry on its business or order a buyout of a member’s interest (N.J.S.A. 42:2C-48).
How a crypto ownership dispute plays out
In these situations, an attorney might start by reviewing corporate documents, then send a formal letter demanding compliance, and obtain access to the company’s financial and ownership records.
When cryptocurrency is involved, preserving evidence is crucial. While blockchain records may show transactions related to the movement of funds, determining who authorized them requires further research. Discovery may therefore involve gaining access to:
- Exchange records
- Wallet histories
- Internal communications
- Expert analysis of on-chain activity
If the cryptocurrency assets are immediately at risk, both parties may seek interim relief from the courts to preserve the status quo until the full contractual and fiduciary issues are resolved.
When disagreements involve automated transactions or blockchain-based agreements, additional contractual questions may arise. Our article on smart contract disputes explains how these conflicts can develop when code execution and the parties’ legal expectations differ.
Resolving the dispute: litigation, arbitration, or a negotiated buyout
Not every partnership dispute needs to end in a courtroom. The appropriate approach depends on the parties’ agreements, the seriousness of the alleged misconduct, and whether they can continue operating together. Some operating agreements require arbitration, while other disputes may be resolved through negotiations that allow one owner to purchase the other’s interest.
| Resolution approach | Main consideration |
| Negotiated buyout | Requires agreement on ownership value, payment terms, and asset transfers |
| Arbitration | May provide a private forum, depending on the arbitration agreement |
| Litigation | May allow court-ordered remedies for misconduct, deadlock, or ownership violations |
Determining the appropriate fair-value or fair-market-value standard can significantly affect the settlement. Our article on how cryptocurrency gets valued in a legal dispute explains why the valuation date and applicable legal standard matter.
How the right agreements prevent these disputes
Although documentation may not prevent all disagreements between owners, it helps define owner behavior if disputes arise. These business agreements should identify voting rights, how ownership can be transferred, the conditions under which a manager has authority, and the process the parties agree to use to resolve disputes.
For companies that use cryptocurrency, these agreements should outline token vesting terms and what would happen if a founder leaves before completing their obligations to the company.
Technical controls should also mirror the legal controls. If a company uses multisig wallets, it should clarify who can approve transactions, when a signer can be removed from the approval group, and what processes will be followed if an authorized party becomes unavailable or uncooperative.
That’s why it’s important to address these issues during business formation, not after a dispute threatens the whole operation.
Facing a dispute with your crypto business partner?
Whether your concerns involve treasury access, ownership rights, or a potential buyout, we can help you evaluate your legal options and work toward a resolution that protects your interests. If you are involved in a business ownership dispute, contact our cryptocurrency litigation team to discuss your situation.
The content in this article is for general informational purposes only. It should not be construed as legal advice or a substitute for legal advice. The information above does not create an attorney-client relationship, nor do prior results guarantee future outcomes. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.